Which of these teams would win?

the first team. Asomugha is arguably the best corner in the game and with Peyton vs. Eli, Peyton always comes out on top, it's just the competitive nature. Peyton wouldn't let his little brother beat him especially if you give him two dynamic receivers. Rememeber when he had Marvin and Reggi in 2004? 49 TD's in basically 15 games.